Does a Smaller Dog Need a Smaller Vaccines?

 

Great question! It’s one I almost never get asked. Rather, I’m often told I must administer only half the recommended dose (one cc) because that’s what the breeder, friend, relative, or Dr. Google says veterinarians should do. Which almost invariably makes most veterinarians roll their eyes…

 

…because everyone knows that the drug companies perform extensive tests on Great Danes and Chihuahuas and everything in between so that it’s crystal clear who needs what and why. Right?

Well … not exactly…

Truth be told, there’s only so much testing a biological (vaccine) manufacturer can be reasonably expected to undertake. Mostly, they need only to prove their vaccine is safe and effective in the species for which the vaccine is intended. The fact that extreme variation within the species exists, however, throws a significant monkey wrench into the works.

So it is that most canine vaccines are tested on “average” dogs. And average dogs are well … average sized. They’re not usually Yorkies, Maltese, Pomeranians, Chihuahuas, or any other sub-ten-pound breed or breed-mix.

Which is perhaps why a greater percentage of small dogs suffer vaccine reactions. Here’s a detailed explanation from a 2005 study on this which appeared in JAVMA:

 

The risk of a VAAE (vaccine-associated adverse events) in this study population was inversely related to a dog’s weight. This weight-response relationship was previously suggested by results of a [2002] study in which dogs of toy breeds had significantly more suspected VAAEs than other dogs, although body weight was not evaluated. The manufacturers’ recommended dose for all vaccines administered in our study was 1 mL regardless of body weight, and all vaccines were from single-dose vials. Vaccines, in contrast to virtually all veterinary pharmaceuticals, are prescribed on a 1-dose-fits-all basis, rather than by body weight. Prelicensing clinical trials investigate the safety of vaccines with doses in excess of label directions but only in a limited number of dogs. The results of this study suggest that trials in dogs that weigh > 10 kg underestimate the expected VAAE rate in smaller dogs.

Prelicensing clinical trials also investigate the safety of vaccines in several hundred dogs at multiple hospital locations, but specific breeds may be under- or overrepresented. Mature weights of dogs of different breeds may vary by 5 to 10 times and occasionally by > 50 times. Therefore, a 1-mL vaccine dose results in a ratio of vaccine volume received per kilogram of body weight that can vary widely.

 

Ultimately, in this retrospective study evaluating 3.5 million full vaccine doses administered to 1.2 million dogs, 38.2 adverse vaccine reactions were observed for every 10,000 dogs. Which is not a big number of vaccine reactions. What was surprising, however, were the following observations:

 

The VAAE rate decreased significantly as body weight increased. Risk was 27% to 38% greater for neutered versus sexually intact dogs and 35% to 64% greater for dogs approximately 1 to 3 years old versus 2 to 9 months old. The risk of a VAAE significantly increased as the number of vaccine doses administered per office visit increased; each additional vaccine significantly increased risk of an adverse event by 27% in dogs ≤ 10 kg (22 lb) and 12% in dogs > 10 kg.

 

So it is that — as I think stands to reason — the injection of multiple vaccines at one time is likelier to yield adverse vaccine events. Moreover, it confirmed (and this time quantified) a previous study’s finding on the higher risks in smaller dogs. Then it went one further with the unexpected timing of greater reaction risk (more for 1-3 year-olds than for 2-9 month-olds), and, the most surprising finding of all (I think), that the risk was higher for spayed and neutered dogs.

So what’s the upshot of all this? Do we not spay and neuter? Do we forego vaccines from 1-3 years of age? Do we alter the timing of vaccines? Do we administer half doses? I think these findings are interesting as a basis for greater study.

By themselves, these numbers do little to alter my already highly individualized take on recommending spays and neuters in my patients. Forgoing vaccines at 1-3 is also a recommendation I’d never consider. Splitting up vaccines so no one gets more than one vaccine per visit is something I’m already jiggy with. But on the half vaccine thing?

Here’s my take:

1. While I do firmly believe that a half dose is likely to be less adverse vaccine event-inducing when administered to any dog, I can’t be sure that a half-dose will be effective in every dog. It’s simply not been investigated.

2. While vaccine manufacturers have not necessarily studied the safety of their vaccines in every size of dog, by now the sheer numbers of vaccinated dogs should serve as a powerful basis on which to assume safety in a wide variety of dogs at the recommended dosage.

So what will I do when the next client in search of a half-dose comes knocking?

  • I’ll explain all of the above. (Maybe I’ll even print it out and give them a few minutes to read it before popping back into the exam room.)
  • If they won’t relent I’ll make a note of it in their chart after administering the half-dose vaccines. All vaccines, that is, except the rabies vaccine.
  • The rabies vaccine will be administered at the full recommended dose. Because — guess what? — I risk my license when I don’t comply with the law on administering the rabies vaccine at the manufacturer’s recommended dose and schedule.

I’d like to think I’m pretty malleable for the most part. I’m willing to take lots of unsolicited advice from my clients and investigate its true worth and make concessions even when I don’t believe the science is there. But I do draw the line at putting my license at risk as some clients have demanded I do.

Author:  Dr. Patty Khuly

Source: http://www.petmd.com/blogs/fullyvetted/2011/july/smaller_dog_smaller_vaccine

 

This entry was posted in Dog Health and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

50 Responses to Does a Smaller Dog Need a Smaller Vaccines?

  1. Oemxwv says:

    cost sildenafil 100mg – price viagra viagra brand

  2. Eapdxl says:

    prednisolone 10mg us – prednisolone 5mg ca order tadalafil 5mg online

  3. Bpmlag says:

    buy augmentin 1000mg online cheap – tadalafil usa cheapest cialis online

  4. Bmbrfy says:

    buy trimethoprim generic – sildenafil 20mg sildenafil 100mg tablets

  5. Atfkhh says:

    order generic cephalexin 500mg – order cleocin pills erythromycin brand

  6. Ojwykb says:

    buy sildenafil generic – buy fildena 50mg generic buy liquid ivermectin

  7. Fgbzhs says:

    brand budesonide – generic cialis disulfiram 500mg uk

  8. Exhefq says:

    order cefuroxime 500mg without prescription – order robaxin generic order cialis 40mg for sale

  9. Xwhpon says:

    cost ampicillin – acillin cost cialis 40mg pills

  10. Aememi says:

    brand amoxicillin 1000mg – order amoxicillin generic order vardenafil 20mg pills

  11. Tuoind says:

    ivermectin for cov 19 – ivermectin 6mg tablets for humans order levitra without prescription

  12. Kyoplv says:

    buy doxycycline 100mg online – buy clomiphene generic oral cialis 20mg

  13. Mtoqnc says:

    cialis 5mg brand – provigil 200mg drug provigil 200mg price

  14. Ordsmd says:

    deltasone 10mg pills – buy generic accutane 20mg brand accutane 20mg

  15. Xezqrc says:

    order amoxil 250mg pills – purchase amoxil cheap viagra

  16. Oxqipn says:

    purchase prednisolone without prescription – viagra 150mg us order sildenafil 100mg online cheap

  17. Jymwta says:

    plaquenil 400mg sale – baricitinib 4mg price buy baricitinib online cheap

  18. Edpegj says:

    metformin 500mg tablet – buy lipitor 40mg pill amlodipine 5mg sale

  19. Oeapyu says:

    tadalafil cheap – flomax cheap flomax 0.2mg price

  20. Mcnxgz says:

    buy ondansetron 8mg – ondansetron pills order valacyclovir without prescription

  21. Quyhbt says:

    buy propecia online – buy ampicillin pill cost cipro 1000mg

  22. Cmdnuo says:

    generic metronidazole – cheap cephalexin 500mg purchase cephalexin

  23. Urmeqq says:

    fildena 100mg pills – order cefuroxime pill sildenafil cost

  24. Dxznvr says:

    best otc ed pills – cialis 5mg kaufen fГјr mГ¤nner original sildenafil 200mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen

  25. Ybrela says:

    buy generic deltasone 40mg – order deltasone 40mg generic prednisolone over the counter

  26. Sojyjq says:

    neurontin 100mg ca – buy neurontin online cheap ivermectin 12mg over counter

  27. Qreqpw says:

    hydroxychloroquine 400mg price – buy plaquenil pill cenforce over the counter

  28. Skabzl says:

    order baricitinib 4mg online – order lisinopril 10mg for sale buy lisinopril 5mg for sale

  29. Cvlavu says:

    prilosec without prescription order omeprazole 20mg without prescription buy methylprednisolone uk

  30. Umdyqy says:

    thesis writing services buy desloratadine generic generic desloratadine

  31. Tenbgr says:

    generic priligy zyloprim cheap order allopurinol 100mg sale

  32. Udfigg says:

    sildenafil over the counter sildenafil pills 25mg cialis 5mg us

  33. Kzirko says:

    order zetia purchase ezetimibe generic purchase domperidone online cheap

  34. Chnjnd says:

    order cyclobenzaprine 15mg ketorolac pill buy clopidogrel 150mg pill

  35. Wshvke says:

    cheap methotrexate 5mg buy methotrexate 2.5mg without prescription metoclopramide 20mg pill

  36. Yrwlkx says:

    sildenafil for men viagra for men buy prednisone generic

  37. Jiigtj says:

    brand accutane 10mg accutane 10mg pills buy sildenafil 100mg pills

  38. Mzlceg says:

    sildenafil 150mg for sale order lamictal 50mg without prescription order cozaar 25mg generic

  39. Sfqhug says:

    nexium 20mg drug nexium 40mg tablet purchase tadalafil online

  40. Fwyfnr says:

    us pharmacy cialis sumatriptan 50mg uk avodart generic

  41. Psytiz says:

    order zantac online mobic 15mg generic tamsulosin oral

  42. Ocpare says:

    zofran 4mg sale order valacyclovir 500mg online order propecia online cheap

  43. Swmgbi says:

    buy diflucan 100mg for sale cipro 500mg price buy generic viagra

  44. Qjknsq says:

    order tadalafil 10mg pill viagra 100mg for sale brand viagra 50mg

  45. Xbfxau says:

    azithromycin 500mg drug purchase metformin buy glucophage 1000mg for sale

  46. Seygdf says:

    buy flagyl online buy fildena 100mg pill generic glucophage 1000mg

  47. Nshmym says:

    cleocin over the counter order erythromycin 500mg pill budesonide uk

  48. Yvefzr says:

    purchase cefuroxime sale cefuroxime 500mg uk tadalafil 10mg pill

  49. Xaknfq says:

    sildenafil 50mg sale cialis 5mg price generic tadalafil 5mg

  50. Tkyofh says:

    where to buy ivermectin purchase mebendazole generic cost retin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.